We were greeted heartily by the crowd of regulars we'd met the last time we'd been at the Almanac. We had a nice meal – I got a steak that beat anything I'd had in the city, and Monica had a salad the size of her torso – and a few drinks, and slowly felt ourselves unwinding. It was a load off to be away from the house, the smell, the creepy feeling the goat had left, and it was amazing to realize just how anxious we had been as the anxiety slipped away into the evening. Midway through our meal, I saw Justin, the son of our house's previous owner, walk in. We'd met with him a few times over the course of the buying process; he'd helped the realtor do the walk-through of the house and had negotiated a lot of the terms with us. I made a mental note to talk to him about the smell in the basement when we finished eating, to see if he'd heard anything about it in the past and had any hints. I thought of asking if he'd heard of anyone nearby missing a goat, but thought better of it. If I had been imagining it, everyone up at the bar would either think I was crazy or drunk.
When we'd finished and paid for our meal, Monica went to the bathroom and I headed up to the bar. I clapped my hand on Justin's back and said hi. He looked excited to see me, maybe a little sloshed. I hadn't been watching him, but he must have been sucking his lagers down pretty fast while we'd been eating.
“Hey, Ed!” he grabbed my hand and shook it energetically with both of his calloused hands. “Good to see you! How's Dad's old place treating you two? Is Monica here?”
“Yeah, she's in the bathroom. The house is great – as beautiful as ever.”
“Fantastic,” he said, slapping me heartily on the back. “Hey, let me get you a beer! What are you drinking tonight? And your lady, let me get her one, too.”
After the appropriate hemming and hawing over who should pay for whose drinks, Monica returned from the bathroom and we settled down next to Justin for a few rounds. He told us about his job and family. He seemed like a really decent sort of person, a “gentleman farmer,” I guess. He owned a plumbing company that had taken off in recent years, so he'd started raising some crops on the land he'd bought with the revenue from our house sale. He seemed happy.
I finally decided it was time to bring up my gripes, and to see if I could press him for more information on the house. If there was anything to the weird problems we’d been having, I thought he might be drunk enough to reveal it without thinking I was out of my mind. “Hey, Justin,” I asked as the bartender set another round before us. “I have to ask you something. You ever hear your dad tell of a nasty smell coming up from the basement of that old place? We love the house, but there's something foul down there that just makes it reek when the weather's warm.”
He paused, looking into his cup for a little while. Maybe a little longer than he should have. But he was pretty far gone. “Well, Ed,” he looked up at me. His eyes were wide. He looked like a cornered animal. “That's a... that's a real old foundation you've got under that house, you know. You knew that when you moved in. Lots of weird old smells in a dirt floor basement like that, in any house. Especially—“ he burped quietly “—especially near the river like that.”
“Oh, yeah, we know. It’s just pretty foul down there sometimes. We’re going to get a floor put in down there, but in the meantime, it'd be great if we had some advice on how to keep the smell down. Any tips?”
“Sure, sure,” he smiled broadly, relief evident on his face as if he’d dodged a very touchy subject. “Well, you know, that old place is bound to have its issues, you know. There could be a plumbing problem, of course, but honestly I don't think much of the piping runs down there. It's mostly outside into the septic...” He took a swig. “It might be more just the age of the place and the dank air, down there, you know. And yeah, the guy who built it was a butcher, you know. All those creepy meat-hooks in the basement. There are bound to be some unpleasant things hanging around after all that, even if it's just a bit of a stink...”
His eyes opened a bit wider as he said it and he turned back to his beer, very much in the manner of someone who had said too much. “I'd be happy to send some guys over there to look at the plumbing if you want,” he mumbled into his beer, then back at me with a wide, open smile. “Free of charge!”
“Oh, Justin, you don't have to do that,” Monica joined in. “We just thought it'd be worth asking about. If your dad had every mentioned the smell or what he did to keep it down, you know. We'll figure it out.” She laid a hand on my leg. When I looked at her, she gave me a piercing stare. She was suspicious of him, I could tell. Something about his behavior was more erratic than the beers he was downing could explain. I nodded.
“It sure is an old place,” I turned to back to Justin. “I love being somewhere with so much history. You don't get much of that in the city where everything's built over so fast.”
He nodded enthusiastically, happy about the change of subject. “Sure does have some history,” he said. “Hell, my dad used to tell me all kinds of stories about that place. Never sure I believed them, though. He was an eccentric guy, and I never spent a whole lot of time in there, what with all the animals.”
I felt Monica's grip on my leg tighten. “Animals?” I said as lightly as I could, my heartbeat picking up. “He had a lot of pets, huh?”
“Sure did,” Justin replied, shaking his head a little. “He was like Noah over there. I always had real bad allergies as a kid, so we never had pets even though Dad was a real animal lover. So when we were all grown up and he bought that place, he just went crazy. He had every kind of animal you can imagine at one time or another. Hell, I think he had a fox or something once. No idea where he got it.”
“A fox! What a thing to have for a pet!” I laughed, feeling Monica’s hand squeeze on my leg again. We were on to something here. “Did he keep it in the house?”
“Well, yes, and no,” he answered. “Most of the critters he had over there came and went as they liked. He had a big fence around the place so they didn't run off, but the door to the house itself was usually open so the animals could come and go as they pleased. He was like Dr. Doolittle over there.” He drank the rest of his beer in several gulps. I ordered him another.
“What a hoot,” I smiled at him. “I'm glad you rehabbed the place before we moved in! I love animals and all, but not in the house!”
He laughed as his next beer was set before him. “I hear you! I mean, if I didn't have allergies I'd be fine with having a dog or a cat inside, you know? But I could never have lived like that, will all kinds of animals in my house.” His face fell a bit, as his memories seemed to take on a more somber note. “Yeah, it was a real zoo. And I hate to say it – I mean I don’t want to be disrespectful to his memory – but by the time Dad passed on, he'd gotten a little strange with the animals. Had them everywhere, only one room of the house to himself and that was his bedroom. People round here...” he looked up and down the bar, then dropped his voice so the other patrons wouldn’t hear him. “They used to call him the ‘Old Goat Man.’”
I clamped my jaw shut to avoid looking too excited. “Really? ‘Goat Man,’ huh?” I goaded him on.
Justin nodded. “Yeah,” he mumbled. “He had so many of them. We tried to convince him to get rid of some of them, but he loved them like they were his own children. Like most people would love a cat or a dog. After a while, well, the damn goats nearly took the place over... Dad wasn't really all there at that point.”
I saw Monica straighten up on the other side of me, her eyes wide. Justin took a long drink, looking forlorn. Trying to salvage the conversation, I smiled again and held my glass up in a toast. “Hey, man,” I said, “at least he did things his own way. Not many people can say that, right?”
Justin looked up at me blearily and clinked his glass to mine, a smile spreading over his face. “You know, Ed, you're right. He did things his way. Here's to The Old Goat Man.”
“Cheers!” Monica and I shared a meaningful glance over our mugs as we toasted the Old Goat Man.
* * *
Monica and I drove home in silence, our thoughts obviously following the same trail as we wound our way back to the house over the country roads. None of the information we were mulling over had explained or helped our situation, and yet there it was, ringing in our ears. “The Old Goat Man. He had so many of them.” My brain was screaming at me that somewhere in Justin’s drunken intimations was an explanation. Maybe one of the goats had stayed in the woods nearby and come to visit its old home, that something logical had to come of this. But logic seemed to fail me every time I thought I’d explained it. My intuition was pushing away all my trains of thought, trying to force something else through: an explanation that wasn't even an explanation. Just a weird idea. Just nonsense. But it wouldn't go away.
When we pulled up to the house, Monica turned to me. “Ed,” she said seriously, “let's pretend, for now, that that conversation with Justin didn't happen. I just want to sleep and not think about it.” Her eyes were a mirror of my thoughts: confused and serious and tired.
I agreed. We went inside and, while Monica got ready for bed, I made myself a little snack of chips and salsa in the kitchen. “The damn goats nearly took the place over...” The words echoed in my head, and I shook it, refusing to let my thoughts continue down the path they were on. Instead I moseyed over to the basement door to let some of the reeking air from the basement out overnight. The door swung open, squeaking just a little. The smell hit me harder than I'd ever experienced it, sending me reeling away, gagging. My hyperactive brain tried to label it – decay, or droppings, or ... death. I shook my head again and forced the thoughts away once again, heading back to the kitchen.
No longer hungry with that smell following me into the room, I stared at my salsa, feeling nauseous. The house was almost silent, except for Monica's small noises from upstairs, but there was a murmur from the basement. I almost sensed it rather than actually hearing it – quiet movement, as if many feet were moving around on the dirt floor, shuffling. I couldn't be sure if I was really hearing anything or just letting my imagination run away with – No. No, that wasn't my imagination. That was a sound. Maybe the fetid air escaping upward. Or maybe…
Bullshit. I was making myself crazy over the drunken ramblings of a plumber whose dad had gone crazy and goat-happy. Mere coincidence, and I damn well knew it, even though my stomach was flopping around like a fish out of water with apprehension. I’d have to show my stomach who was boss and go down there, take a look around. Show it, and my growing fear, that there was nothing out of the ordinary going on here. Teach the hair on my neck to lie back down.
I took a deep breath and walked to the open doorway, holding my breath against the stench from below. I flicked the light switch on the wall. Nothing happened. The old bulb hanging from the ceiling down there must have blown out. Perfect timing. I took a deep breath through my mouth to avoid smelling the air, and took a few steps down before stopping to let my eyes adjust.
There were faint stirring sounds coming from below as before. Probably rats or bugs, I told myself. I peered downward, my hand tight on the railing and my every hair standing on end. My stomach flipped particularly violently and, then – there it was. That same goat. Standing a few steps below me. Chewing on the same piece of flesh and staring at me.
Le Gross National Happiness
16 years ago

